Fish Feeding and Rapid Foraging Behavior Switching by Gray Whales (Eschrichtius robustus) in California
- Behavior
- Foraging
Abstract
Gray whales (Eschrichtius robustus) evolved to suction feed on benthic invertebrates and typically do not consume adult fish. Yet, these whales are flexible foragers, occasionally skim feeding on planktonic invertebrates and rarely lunge feeding on fish, the latter according to anecdotal accounts. We documented the unusual phenomenon of multiple gray whales predating dense schools of anchovy over a sustained period (22 days) in June 2022 at Pacifica, California, in the Gulf of the Farallones. Analysis of 11,265 photos and 11 video clips (totaling 4 min 16 s) for behavior and whale identification resulted in a total of 165 foraging events by six identified gray whales. Attribution of foraging behavior to the most active individuals was achieved by matching left pectoral fins, visible during lateralized feeding behavior. Whales rolled onto their right sides in 96% of near-surface side-swimming bouts. Another behavior, first photographed here, was dynamic surface lunge feeding by one gray whale. Five gray whales interspersed fish feeding with benthic suction feeding evidenced by sediment streaming: prey type switching was executed rapidly, in less than 1 minute in several instances, the shortest intervals reported for a baleen whale. Similar results were obtained for foraging behavior switching (continuous side-swimming or intermittent lunging) in pursuit of fish. Four photo-identified Pacifica whales were sighted in San Francisco Bay/Gulf of the Farallones, one of which was also matched to the Pacific Coast Feeding Group. Such local and regional connections warrant efforts to determine whether gray whales use this area as a migratory stopover site or for summer foraging, or both. Our observations confirm gray whale behavioral plasticity and opportunistic exploitation of food resources in mid-latitudes, which may enhance their resilience to climate change.
Webber, M.A., Keener, W., Markowitz, T.M., Chamberlin, D., Allen, D., Lane, R.S., Slaathaug, J. M., Rodriguez, P. N., George, K., O’Hern, J.E., 2024. Fish feeding and rapid foraging behavior switching by gray whales (Eschrichtius robustus) in California. Aquatic Mammals, 50(2), pp.132-151.
foraging
Kathi George
Tim Markowitz
Julia O'Hern
Marc Webber
Bekah Lane
Bill Keener
Pilar Rodriguez
gray whales, fish, feeding, foraging, foraging behavior, behavior switching, lunge feeding, climate change
Meet The Experts
{"image":"\/People\/Portrait\/cropped-images\/marc-webber-0-196-1204-940-1618436847.jpg","alt":"Marc Webber","title":"Marc Webber","text":"Cetacean Field Research Associate","link_url":"https:\/\/www.marinemammalcenter.org\/person\/marc-webber","link_text":"Read Bio"}
{"image":"\/People\/Portrait\/kathi-george.jpg","alt":"Kathi George","title":"Kathi George","text":"Director of Cetacean Conservation Biology","link_url":"https:\/\/www.marinemammalcenter.org\/person\/kathi-george","link_text":"Read Bio"}
{"image":"\/People\/Portrait\/timothy-markowitz.jpg","alt":"Tim Markowitz","title":"Tim Markowitz","text":"Cetacean Field Research Associate","link_url":"https:\/\/www.marinemammalcenter.org\/person\/tim-markowitz","link_text":"Read Bio"}
{"image":"\/People\/Portrait\/cropped-images\/julia-ohern-0-41-720-562-1602604782.jpg","alt":"Julia O'Hern","title":"Julia O'Hern","text":"Associate Director, Cetacean Conservation Biology","link_url":"https:\/\/www.marinemammalcenter.org\/person\/julia-ohern","link_text":"Read Bio"}
{"image":"\/People\/Portrait\/cropped-images\/bekah-lane-650-2-4421-3454-1639429863.jpg","alt":"Bekah Lane","title":"Bekah Lane","text":"Cetacean Field Research Specialist","link_url":"https:\/\/www.marinemammalcenter.org\/person\/bekah-lane","link_text":"Read Bio"}
{"image":"\/People\/Portrait\/cropped-images\/bill-keener-0-0-3030-2314-1601930964.jpg","alt":"Bill Keener","title":"Bill Keener","text":"Cetacean Field Research Associate","link_url":"https:\/\/www.marinemammalcenter.org\/person\/bill-keener","link_text":"Read Bio"}
{"image":"\/People\/Portrait\/cropped-images\/pilar-rodriguez-2-163-1432-1118-1707171460.jpg","alt":"Pilar Rodriguez","title":"Pilar Rodriguez","text":"Cetacean Conservation Biology Apprentice","link_url":"https:\/\/www.marinemammalcenter.org\/person\/pilar-rodriguez","link_text":"Read Bio"}
Related Publications
{"image":"\/Animals\/Patients\/Harbor seals\/hs-by-bill-hunnewell-c-the-marine-mammal-center.jpg","alt":"harbor seal in a life preserver enrichment item","title":"Enrichment as a Tool for Rehabilitating Harbor Seals","link_url":"https:\/\/www.marinemammalcenter.org\/publications\/enrichment-as-a-tool-for-rehabilitating-harbor-seals","label":"Research Paper"}
{"image":"\/Animals\/Wild\/Harbor porpoise\/cropped-images\/harbor-porpoises-foraging-by-marc-webber-c-the-marine-mammal-center-4-0-1276-996-1618438446.jpg","alt":"harbor porpoises eating a large fish","title":"Prey-Related Suffocation in Harbor Porpoises","link_url":"https:\/\/www.marinemammalcenter.org\/publications\/prey-related-suffocation-in-harbor-porpoises","label":"Research Paper"}
{"image":"\/Animals\/Wild\/Humpback whale\/cropped-images\/humpback-whale-breach-golden-gate-by-pilar-rodriguez-c-the-marine-mammal-center-noaa-permit-26532-647-0-1710-1336-1702426697.jpg","alt":"humpback whale breaches with Golden Gate Bridge in the background","title":"New Urban Habitat for Endangered Humpback Whales: San Francisco Bay","link_url":"https:\/\/www.marinemammalcenter.org\/publications\/new-urban-habitat-for-endangered-humpback-whales-san-francisco-bay","label":"Research Paper"}
Recent News
{"image":"\/Animals\/Patients\/California sea lions\/2023\/cropped-images\/csl-thunder-photo-by-bill-hunnewell-c-the-marine-mammal-center-214-50-2868-2240-1713984238.jpg","alt":"California sea lion Thunder","title":"30 Percent of Patients in 2023 Experienced Some Form of Human or Dog Disturbance","link_url":"https:\/\/www.marinemammalcenter.org\/news\/30-percent-of-patients-in-2023-experienced-some-form-of-human-or-dog-disturbance","label":"Press Release","date":"2024-04-24 02:00:00"}
30 Percent of Patients in 2023 Experienced Some Form of Human or Dog Disturbance
April 24, 2024
Read More{"image":"\/Animals\/Patients\/Harbor seals\/2024\/cropped-images\/hs-sandia-by-bill-hunnewell-c-the-marine-mammal-center-313-14-4124-3222-1713562157.jpg","alt":"A newborn seal pup with a fluffy lanugo coat looks up. ","title":"Pupping Season Spotlight: Caring for an Orphaned Harbor Seal Pup","link_url":"https:\/\/www.marinemammalcenter.org\/news\/pupping-season-spotlight-caring-for-an-orphaned-harbor-seal-pup","label":"Patient Update","date":"2024-04-22 02:00:00"}
Pupping Season Spotlight: Caring for an Orphaned Harbor Seal Pup
April 22, 2024
Read More{"image":"\/Misc\/Graphics\/cropped-images\/climate-change-graphic-giant-earth-shutterstock-1798-6-5113-3994-1680046432.jpg","alt":"An Earth Day graphic of people holding the planet, recycling, planting a tree and moving a solar panel.","title":"5 Ways to Celebrate Earth Day","link_url":"https:\/\/www.marinemammalcenter.org\/news\/5-ways-to-celebrate-earth-day","label":"News Update","date":"2024-04-18 02:00:00"}
{"image":"\/Animals\/Patients\/Hawaiian monk seals\/2024\/cropped-images\/hms-rs10-release-photo-c-the-marine-mammal-center-noaa-permit-24359-0-0-966-755-1712699238.jpg","alt":"Hawaiian monk seal RS10 is released and heads toward the water","title":"Endangered Hawaiian Monk Seal Back Home on Kaua\u02bbi After Receiving Life-Saving Care for Ingested Fishing Gear","link_url":"https:\/\/www.marinemammalcenter.org\/news\/endangered-hawaiian-monk-seal-back-home-on-kauai-after-receiving-life-saving-care-for-ingested-fishing-gear","label":"Press Release","date":"2024-04-09 02:00:00"}
Endangered Hawaiian Monk Seal Back Home on Kauaʻi After Receiving Life-Saving Care for Ingested Fishing Gear
April 9, 2024
Read More